|
|
Post by captainjack on May 26, 2007 18:40:00 GMT -5
YEESSS!!!! i thought it rocked!! probably the funniest one out of the 3! i really thought it was ALOT different from the 1st 2! just felt different! yeah, i was not confused at all either, and it definately didn't seem very long, cause there was constant action!(i thought it actually seemed a little bit rushed) ok, i thought there were some parts that could've been done better, like the whole Calypso scene(imo, it was a bit dumb). and maybe the W/E love scene, that was somewhat weird. and there were some questions that weren't answered: 1. what WAS Jack's mark on Beckett? 2. how did Jack and Tia Dalma know each other? 3. who killed the Kraken? 4. i thought the pirates were supposed to have a secret weapon, was it really Calypso? cause she only sort've helped them. 5. why can't Liz just sail with Will on the FD, why'd she have to stay on that island? those are all i can think of right now, but why did they keep showing those coin things? i thought they were supposed to be the 9 pieces of 8, but it turned out to be junk!?! (only Jack's was 1 of the coins) and was that boy in the beginning sposed to be significant at all? but as Jack says "all this pales into utter insignidudeance", cause the rest was so awesome!!! some of my favorite parts were the whole locker scene w/ all those Jacks!! Hilarious!! and that wedding battle scene, for a second i thought Liz HAD chosen Barbossa!!! (i actually found myself pulling for Jack/Liz!! i thought Will really did die for a while, horrible!) Lol, funny!! it even managed to really surprise me, i was worried about a few things before i saw it. like when Jack says, "CJS the last pirate", turns out he was only argueing with Barbossa! and that Jack that was part of the FD, haha, it was sooo funny about his brain!!! i also thought that the DJ pirate guy with like the extendable sharkhead, i thought it was gonna be another Kraken type thingy! really happy these things didn't turn out like i thought they were! anyways, yeah at first i wasn't so sure i liked the ending, but i think i do now. so will Will be free of the curse if he and Liz stay true to each other through 10 years? i think thats what happens anyway. oh, i felt very sorry for poor Jack, sailing off in that little dinghy! haha, he's got the charts though! it just made me a little sad to have them all split up though. well, i'm going to see it again tomorrow!! Yay! i'll always love this movie, just like the first 2!! and i'm really sick of all these so called critics saying how much the past 2 sucked!! (my so-called friends don't help either)go pick on someone else, leave the best series EVER alone!!! they just make me SOOO mad!! i gave it a very well-deserved 5 stars!! oh, and they HAVE to do a Pirates 4!!! i did really go at 8 on Thursday, just didn't get to write till now. i am very happy to say that every single show at my theater was sold out!!! GO PIRATES!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by rapunzelq2 on May 27, 2007 0:46:08 GMT -5
well for who killed the kraken.. davy jones killed it because he didn't want the kraken to destroy other ppl since beckett had the compass.. also bout liz not goin with will.. is cuz she couldn't survive underthewater unlik will... that was the sad part! =( i cried a lot! the coin things were to summon the pirates lords also at the end of the end of the movie u see will's son and will CAN't become free... if he does he will be killed cuz thats the only way for him to become free... and he'll live on eternally since his heart is cut oout and liz will die and soo he will have ALL of that pain that davy jones had.... thats all of the answers i know... so i hoped i helped!
|
|
|
|
Post by captainjack on May 27, 2007 17:44:09 GMT -5
yup, you helped, thanks a lot rapunzelq2!!!! ;D just saw it again today, and Beckett actually was talking about how he had ordered Davy to kill the Kraken and now its sooo obvious that Liz can't go with Will, why didn't i notice this before!?! oh but Will did come back forever(cause he and Liz stayed true to each other), the screenwriters said this in a statement they made. well now i COMPLETELY loved it, forget about the complaints i made before!!!(just had to see it again!) it be my favorite PotC movie!! can't wait for the DVD to come out!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by rapunzelq2 on May 28, 2007 14:20:38 GMT -5
^^ but they can't be together 4ever.. hes dead... he has his heart cut out and the only way for him to get out of living in the sea is for someone to stab his heart and take over the ship... =(
|
|
|
|
Post by flaviasparrow on May 29, 2007 3:04:36 GMT -5
no.. if elizabeth stayed on dat island [lyk she did] lyk calypso was supposed to the curse would be broken.. she just had to not see him for 10 years.. which is wat apperently happened... davy jones has to keep being the captain because calypso wasnt there when he came bak  also if yous heard beckett sed something something "lyk when i told you to kill your 'little' pet" meaning kracken... it was too big to control.. so they killed it... and about the coins... barbossa said something about it cant remember.. must listen lol and also... calypso was MEANT to help them lol and also the mark... they didnt say it in the movie but it was jack freeing slaves... when he was supposed to do a job so becektt branded him a P |
|
|
|
Post by flaviasparrow on May 29, 2007 3:06:42 GMT -5
and sunk he's ship the wicked wench... later jack asked davy jones to bring it bak re-naming it the black pearl  but owes hes soul after 13 yrs of being her captain |
|
|
|
Post by rapunzelq2 on May 29, 2007 22:37:50 GMT -5
REALLY the curse would be broken??? well then whose the flying dutchman captain now? and does will lie now...??
|
|
|
|
Post by captainjack on Jun 2, 2007 9:05:30 GMT -5
Yeah, the curse was broken and the flash of green means that a soul returns from the dead, so Will is still alive! he's immortal, as long as his heart remains safe.(actually, Jack, Barbossa and Will have all kinda been dead but are still alive!) but yeah, don't know who's gonna be captain then, or if nobody has too. oh and thanks too flaviasparrow! so that's really supposed to be the mark Jack left on Beckett? i thought it was something like what he did to Jack!?!
|
|
|
|
Post by rapunzelq2 on Jun 2, 2007 11:15:22 GMT -5
hmm IDK... i thot he culd only step on land EVERY 10 years... but the curse s on him 4ever.. and sumone HAS to be the captain of the flying dutchman cuz then who is going to send the dead people to their death place?
|
|
|
|
Post by captainjack on Jun 4, 2007 18:26:53 GMT -5
o.k, i'm not really sure about all that! but i think the job was always just supposed to be temporary and no one will have to do it anymore. idk. anyways maybe they'll explain that if they make a fourth!
|
|
|
|
Post by rapunzelq2 on Jun 4, 2007 20:00:41 GMT -5
i'm postive bout my answer =/ soo ya
|
|
katie
New Sailor
Posts: 19
|
Post by katie on Jul 12, 2007 10:54:43 GMT -5
Yeah.. I thought the curse would be with him forever. And I think I like it better that way. Otherwise it's just another come and go storyline that doesn't stay with the film.... and if there is a fourth one it would be kinda ruined if he just came back :/
|
|
also if yous heard beckett sed something something "lyk when i told you to kill your 'little' pet" meaning kracken... it was too big to control.. so they killed it... 
but owes hes soul after 13 yrs of being her captain